Randomized trial finds peer-supported online therapy improved anxiety after discharge for low-risk chest pain, with the largest difference among patients with severe anxiety
Some patients returned to the emergency department with the same chest pain that had brought them in before, even after an evaluation ruled out a heart attack or another emergency. For emergency physician and Regenstrief Institute research scientist Paul I. Musey Jr., M.D., M.S., those repeat visits raised a question: What could emergency departments offer patients who also screened positive for clinically significant anxiety?
A positive screen can identify patients who may benefit from treatment, but connecting them with care after discharge can be difficult, especially where access to therapists is limited. For emergency clinicians and health systems, the question is what kind of follow-up they can offer. In the PACER randomized clinical trial, Musey and colleagues from Indiana University School of Medicine found that a self-paced online program with guided peer support improved anxiety symptoms more than an enhanced primary care referral over 12 months.
Testing three approaches to follow-up care
The trial enrolled 375 adults with low-risk chest pain and elevated anxiety scores at six Indiana University Health emergency departments. All participants received brief education about anxiety and chest pain. Researchers then randomly assigned them to enhanced primary care referral, self-paced online cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) with guided peer support, or traditional therapist-delivered CBT via telehealth.
In the online program, participants worked through CBT modules and could discuss how the material applied to their lives with a certified peer support specialist who had lived experience with anxiety. “We wanted to figure out a different way to provide somebody with that human touch,” Musey said.
The largest difference was among patients with severe anxiety
Anxiety symptoms improved in all three groups. On the trial’s primary measure, the seven-item Generalized Anxiety Disorder scale (GAD-7), scores improved by an average of 1.22 points more in the peer-supported online CBT group than in the primary care referral group (95% CI, 0.01–2.43). Among participants who entered the trial with severe anxiety, that difference was 2.8 points (95% CI, 1.0–4.6).
The difference between therapist-delivered CBT and primary care referral did not reach statistical significance on the GAD-7. On a separate measure that asked participants how their anxiety had changed overall, people in both CBT groups had higher odds of reporting improvement than those in the referral group.
Turning a positive screen into a referral for treatment
For health systems designing follow-up after an emergency visit, a self-paced program with peer support offers a way to provide structured CBT without a therapist leading every session. Participation in treatment varied, and all six trial sites were part of one health system. Further research could show how well the approach works in other settings and how much peer support contributes to the improvement.
“The emergency department was developed as a place to rule out life threats,” Musey said. “But as you continue to experience symptoms, we can also be a place that can help you navigate to where you need to go and the next steps in treatment.”
Musey wants to study how emergency departments could use the electronic health record to make anxiety screening, referral and follow-up part of routine care. He also wants to compare the online program with and without peer support.
In addition to first author Paul I. Musey Jr., M.D., M.S., the study’s authors were Regenstrief Institute Research Scientist Kurt Kroenke, M.D., Jill Nault Connors, PhD, MSSW, Timothy E. Stump, M.A., Yelena Chernyak, PhD, Kevin Prather, MSW, Chet Montgomery and Patrick O. Monahan, PhD from the Indiana University School of Medicine. They all express their gratitude to all the patients and stakeholders who helped design this study and participated.
The study, “Telehealth Treatment of Anxiety in Patients With Low-Risk Chest Pain in the Emergency Department: The PACER Randomized Clinical Trial,” was published in JAMA Internal Medicine.
Paul I. Musey Jr., M.D., M.S., FACEP
In addition to his role at Regenstrief Institute, Dr. Paul Musey is the Eskenazi Health Foundation Scholar of Emergency Medicine and Interim Chair for the Indiana University School of Medicine (IUSM) Department of Emergency Medicine. He is originally from Atlanta, Georgia and received his B.S. in Chemistry from Georgia State University in 2005 before graduating from Emory University School of Medicine in 2009.
About Regenstrief Institute
Founded in 1969 in Indianapolis, the Regenstrief Institute is a key research partner to Indiana University that pioneers transformative, interdisciplinary solutions for a healthier world. Regenstrief serves as a neutral research partner to health systems, industry and government, independently evaluating how health technologies and models of care perform in real-world settings. Regenstrief research scientists have advanced major healthcare innovations around the globe, including early electronic medical records, one of the oldest and largest repositories of interoperable health data in the country and global health data standards, including LOINC®, that facilitate the exchange and use electronic health information.
Sam Regenstrief, a nationally successful entrepreneur from Connersville, Indiana, founded the institute with the goal of making healthcare more efficient and accessible for everyone. His vision continues to guide the institute’s research mission.






